...

Comparison of fire training solutions: Which one to choose?

Dec 6, 2024 | Immersive technologies

comparison of fire training solutions: which one to choose?

You often wonder which fire training solution choose between firebox, the virtual simulator or the fire truck… ?

After this comparison of training solutions We'll show you which tool is best suited to your needs.

Each of these solutions has its own benefits and can be chosen according to the company's specific needs, budget, available space and desired level of training realism.

What is the firebox?

The fire pan is a traditional method, using a controlled live fire for training.

Providing hands-on experience:

    • Use of a real fire controlled
    • Handling direct extinguishers
    • Possibility to simulate different types of fires (gas, deep fryer, etc.)

This method offers a realistic experience, but requires a secure outdoor area, favorable weather conditions and is very limited in terms of verifying overall knowledge (complete fire process).

 

Highlights Weaknesses
- Live fire
- Easy to install
- Unrealistic setting
- Impossible to validate the entire process
- Environmental impact (smoke and pollution)
- Risk of burns
- Outdoor use only
- Varied scenarios
- Deja vu

What is a fire truck?

The fire truck, also known as a mobile unit, is a practical and realistic training solution.
This is a specially equipped vehicle for fire training.

This type of training allows :

    • Exercises on real lights in a secure environment
    • Visit handling fire extinguishers on different types of fires (deep fryer, electric, etc.)
    • From evacuation simulations in the smoke
    • A theoretical and practical training in the same space

The truck can usually accommodate up to 10 people per session, with training sessions lasting from 1 hour to 3h30.

Highlights Weaknesses
- Live fire
- Independent of weather conditions
- Unrealistic setting
- Impossible to validate the entire process
- High costs (purchase, maintenance and fee per trainee)
- Large space required
- Environmental impact (smoke, water)

What are laser extinguishers?

This modern solution uses laser-equipped extinguishers and screens simulating fires a bit like a video game, but with a real educational purpose.

It offers :

    • Installation quick and easy
    • Indoor training facilities without risk
    • A simulation without the drawbacks real fire

It's a safe, clean way to train, ideal for indoor spaces where you can't build a real fire.

Highlights Weaknesses
- Fire realism
- Maximum safety
- Infinitely reusable
- No consumables
- Indoor training available
- Lack of realism (no heat or smoke)
- Limited scenarios
- Initial investment

What is fire risk e-learning?

L'e-learning is a online training to acquire theoretical knowledge of fire safety.

It enables :

    • Theoretical learning remote
    • Evaluations by MCQS
    • Can be combined with a practical part (mix-learning)

It's flexible because everyone can follow the course at their own pace, but it lacks practical experience. That's why it's often combined with other methods.

 

Highlights Weaknesses
- 24/7 accessibility
- Distance learning
- Customizable to your needs
- Real-time progress monitoring
- Reduced cost
- Lack of interactivity
- No realistic context
- Difficult to assess practical skills
- Internet connection
- Less commitment

What is a virtual reality fire simulator?

This solution uses virtual reality to immerse participants in fire scenarios in a totally virtual environment.

    • An experience realistic and secure
    • Handling connected extinguishers
    • The simulation of various environments and scenarios of fire outbreak
    • No need for a large space

It's a highly immersive and engaging experience, which can take place in any interior space.
FIRE VR is a perfect example of what virtual reality can achieve for fire training.

Highlights Weaknesses
- Total immersion
- Unlimited variety of scenarios
- No risk for trainees
- Training available anywhere
- Cost of equipment
- Misses the sensation of warmth

What is an augmented reality fire simulator?

Visit augmented reality combine real environment and virtual elements to create ultra-realistic fire scenarios directly on participants' workstations.

    • Superimposing virtual elements (fire, smoke) to the real environment
    • Can be used in premises of the company
    • Interaction with real objects (extinguishers) in a virtual scenario

It's a good compromise between realism and safety, allowing training to be contextualized in the real working environment.

FIRE AR a brand-new solution that makes perfect use of augmented reality to simulate fire starts in the learners' real-life environment.

Highlights Weaknesses
- Comprehensive skills check
- Unlimited scenarios
- Maximum safety
- Infinitely reusable
- No consumables
- Indoor training available
- Misses the sensation of warmth
- Initial investment

Comparatif des solution de formation

Comparatif des solution de formation

Technology Process validation Situation Realism Harmless to the environment Risks of use Consumable use Main asset Main Fault
Fire pan NO NO NO YES YES Real Fire Limited pedagogy
Mobile Fire Unit YES NO NO YES YES Real Fire Limited Space Fire Realism
Electronic Fire Extinguishers NO NO YES NO NO - Unrealistic situation
Smoke emitters NO YES YES NO YES Group work Limited pedagogy
Virtual Reality YES YES YES NO NO Safe Immersion No contact with a fire extinguisher
Augmented Reality YES YES YES NO NO Using a real fire extinguisher Setting the scene

How do you choose the right fire training solution?

To choose the right fire training in 2024, several key factors need to be taken into account:

    • Visit specific needs of your company
    • Visit budget available
    • L'space at your disposal
    • The level of realism desired
    • Visit constraints environmental
    • L'commitment learners

The technologies virtual and augmented realitysuch as FIRE VR and FIRE AR d'IRWINOmeet these criteria by offering an immersive, safe and adapted training experience.

These innovative solutions make it possible not only to comply with legal obligationsThey also significantly improve learner engagement and retention. They offer a modern alternative and efficient traditional methodswhile adapting to the specific constraints of each company.

5 Avantages des formations incendie en réalité virtuelle/augmentée

    1. Engagement des apprenants : L’aspect immersif et interactif augmente la motivation et la rétention des informations.
    2. Sécurité accrue : Contrairement au bac à feu, ces technologies éliminent tout risque de brûlure ou d’inhalation de fumées toxiques.
    3. Répétabilité : Les exercices peuvent être répétés autant de fois que nécessaire sans coût supplémentaire.
    4. Flexibilité et adaptabilité : Les scénarios peuvent être facilement adaptés à différents environnements de travail et types d’incendies.
    5. Impact environnemental réduit : Pas d’émission de fumées ni de consommation d’eau ou d’agents extincteurs.

5 Avantages des formations incendie en réalité virtuelle/augmentée

    1. Engagement des apprenants : L'aspect immersif et interactif augmente la motivation et la rétention des informations.
    2. Sécurité accrue : Contrairement au bac à feu, ces technologies éliminent tout risque de brûlure ou d'inhalation de fumées toxiques.
    3. Répétabilité : Les exercices peuvent être répétés autant de fois que nécessaire sans coût supplémentaire.
    4. Flexibilité et adaptabilité : Les scénarios peuvent être facilement adaptés à différents environnements de travail et types d'incendies.
    5. Impact environnemental réduit : Pas d'émission de fumées ni de consommation d'eau ou d'agents extincteurs.

5 Avantages des formations incendie en réalité virtuelle/augmentée

    1. Engagement des apprenants : L'aspect immersif et interactif augmente la motivation et la rétention des informations.
    2. Sécurité accrue : Contrairement au bac à feu, ces technologies éliminent tout risque de brûlure ou d'inhalation de fumées toxiques.
    3. Répétabilité : Les exercices peuvent être répétés autant de fois que nécessaire sans coût supplémentaire.
    4. Flexibilité et adaptabilité : Les scénarios peuvent être facilement adaptés à différents environnements de travail et types d'incendies.
    5. Impact environnemental réduit : Pas d'émission de fumées ni de consommation d'eau ou d'agents extincteurs.

FIRE VR: fire training in virtual reality

This fire simulator at virtual reality with virtualized fire extinguishersoffers a unique immersive experience, allowing trainees to practice ultra-realistic fire scenarios in a virtual environment.

  • 3 working environments (Commercial, Industrial and U&J ERP)
  • The potential creation of more than 50 scenarios of fire starts.
  • Sessions on 3 to 6 minutes by trainees to check knowledge acquired.
  • A simulation of immersive fire start

FIRE VR enables companies to train their staff in fire-fighting processes, safely and with striking realism.

>>> Learn more about our virtual fire simulator

FIRE AR: fire training in augmented reality

Fire training tailored to your professional reality. Visit merging the real working environment with virtual elements (fire, smoke, safety equipment), this simulator at augmented reality offers a unique, highly contextualized training experience.

  • The virtual installation of FIRE STARTS and safety equipment in the learner's real-life environment
  • The creation of original exercises in less than 3 minutes
  • A simulator that works indoors and outdoor over several hundred m2
  • A system lightweight and affordable

With FIRE ARtransform your workspace into a training ground for optimum preparation in the face of fire hazards.

>>> Learn more about our augmented reality fire simulator ?

Which fire training solution to choose in 2024?

In 2024, the choice of a fire training solution must focus on modern technologies. Fire training virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) stand out as the best options, offering undeniable advantages in terms of cost, d'impact and environmental retention information.

These technologies enable immersive and safeThis eliminates the risks associated with traditional methods such as the fire pan. What's more, they promote better memorization thanks to their engaging appearance.
With reduced long-term operating costs and a minimal environmental footprint, the VR and AR solutions are a wise investment for any company.

Contact us to find out more about our virtual and augmented reality training to explore the possibilities offered by these technologies for risk prevention.

Other articles

en_USEnglish